Oct
10

Dominate AI and Traditional Search: 7 Critical Google Ranking Factors for the New SEO Era

Master the 7 Google ranking factors that dominate both traditional SEO and AI search. Learn how to future-proof your visibility in 2025 and beyond.

If you want better SEO results, you need to understand the most important Google ranking factors that are working right now. The search landscape has fundamentally changed, with the rise of AI Overviews, AI Mode, and powerful Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT, which use traditional search results as their source of truth.

This article will show you the exact strategies required to drive number one rankings in Google's traditional search results while simultaneously optimizing for visibility within the new AI platforms. Drawing upon a decade of successful SEO campaign leadership and systems that have produced predictable number one rankings for thousands of agencies and clients, we will break down the seven most critical factors.

Like the content to show you're ready, and let's begin the deep dive into the new era of search engine optimization.

The 7 Essential Google Ranking Factors for 2025

The core of SEO remains constant, but the methods must adapt to serve both the human user and the AI retrieval systems. Our focus will be on factors that directly influence your performance across Google's traditional search engine results pages (SERPs) and AI platforms.

1. Indexation and Crawlability: The Foundation of Visibility

It’s a simple truth: your page cannot rank if it isn't indexed. Furthermore, AI platforms like ChatGPT retrieve their information from content that is already successfully crawled and indexed by search engines. Therefore, optimizing for indexation is the absolute first step toward succeeding in both traditional and AI search.

Here are four crucial ways to improve crawling and indexing on your website:

A. Nail the Basics

Ensure the fundamental elements of your website are configured correctly:

  1. Verify that your robots.txt file explicitly allows all necessary crawlers (Googlebot, Bingbot, etc.).
  2. Maintain an updated sitemap and submit it to Google Search Console to guide crawlers.
  3. Ensure you are not using a noindex tag on any page you actively want to rank.

B. Intelligent Internal Linking

Internal links are the roadways for search engine crawlers. A page that is hard to find through internal links is less likely to be crawled and indexed frequently.

  • Crawl Depth: Your goal should be to ensure that all pages on your website are no more than three clicks deep from the homepage.
  • Coverage: Your most important pages must have sufficient internal link coverage.
  • Actionable Tip: Run a Screaming Frog crawl. Check the Crawl Depth and Unique Inlinks columns. For pages with high crawl depth, consider adding critical commercial pages to the sitewide navigation or footer. Then, use internal links on those commercial pages to send crawlers even deeper to relevant supporting content. This ensures even your most important tool pages, for instance, are easily accessible to crawlers and users alike.

C. Prioritize HTML over JavaScript for AI Crawling

While modern coding platforms like Lovable and Replit are fantastic, many use JavaScript out of the box. A critical flaw here is that current AI platforms like ChatGPT cannot effectively crawl JavaScript.

  • The Solution: HTML is a proven, reliable, and inherently crawlable language. To ensure your content is available for both traditional ranking and AI retrieval, avoid heavily relying on JavaScript for your core content structure. You don't need to reinvent the wheel; stick with what is proven to be crawlable by both Google and LLMs.

D. Optimize Loading Speed (Indirect Factor)

Loading speed is an indirect ranking factor because its primary influence is on user experience. However, from an indexation perspective, crawlers have low tolerance for slow websites.

  • The 3-Second Rule: If your pages are loading slower than 3 seconds, crawlers—especially those related to LLMs—may skip them entirely to maintain efficiency. Optimizing speed is essential to ensure your content is fully scanned.

2. Matching Search Intent: Creating the Perfect Fit

The key to succeeding with this ranking factor is to step into the shoes of the searcher. What is the user actually hoping to find when they type a query?

  • The Head Keyword Trap: Broad, "head" keywords, such as "SEO," are terrible to target because the search intent is too vague (the possibilities are endless: a definition, a tool, a guide, a job). It’s nearly impossible to perfectly match the search intent for such a term.
  • The Context Solution: Keywords with more context, such as "best SEO tools for agency," have a much clearer intent. This context allows you to create a perfectly relevant page.
  • Actionable Tip: When in doubt, go to Google and analyze the current SERP. For the example "best SEO tools for agency," the results clearly show that listicles are the common format. Match the format that is already proven to work and satisfy user intent.

3. Content Relevance and Differentiation: Covering All Bases

Content relevance goes beyond simple keyword inclusion; it’s about topic coverage and providing information gain.

A. Topic Coverage Over Keyword Injection

Uniqueness matters because of information gain, a concept built into Google's algorithms. Google and LLMs might reward pages that add something new to the discussion on a topic. However, being too unique can have adverse effects if you miss the core information expected by the user.

  • The Strategy: Start with relevance and then focus on differentiation. Use a content optimization tool (like Rankability's Content Optimizer) to enter your target keyword phrase. The report will show relevant topics that your top competitors have already covered. You must cover as many of these same topics as possible to ensure your page performs well. Focus on comprehensive topic coverage, not just injecting keywords.

B. Word Count as a Target

While a specific word count is not a direct Google ranking factor, the word count range provided by tools is typically based on the median word count of the top-ranking competitors. This serves as a sensible target for your writer, as it suggests the depth required to achieve comprehensive topic coverage that satisfies user intent.

C. Strategic Keyword Placement

To ensure maximum relevance and clarity for both users and crawlers, strategically place your primary keyword and its variants:

  • URL, Title Tag, and Meta Description
  • H1 Tag
  • First Sentence
  • A variant in your first H2 Tag
  • One last time in your Conclusion

4. Topical Authority: Building Thematic Trust

You must avoid "random acts of SEO content." Every piece of content you create needs to fit within a broader strategy—a topic cluster.

  • The Cluster Strategy: Focus on one topic cluster at a time.
    1. Core Page: Start by optimizing your main core product page or service page (e.g., Rankability's AI Analyzer).
    2. Pillar Asset: Create a primary pillar listicle asset that targets a broad, high-volume keyword related to your core page (e.g., "best AI search rank tracking tools").
    3. Supporting Assets: Build supporting assets that target more specific, long-tail keywords. Examples include: "best competitor alternatives," "competitor review," or "competitor vs. your brand."
    4. Repeat: Repeat this process for 5 to 10 of your top competitors, creating content that targets their brand names and products.
  • The Benefit: By creating more topic support, you generate more opportunities for internal links within the cluster. This means if one page in your cluster earns a backlink, it will lift the performance of the entire cluster, establishing thematic authority in Google's eyes.

5. Backlink Quality: The Trust Signal 🛡️

You can perfectly execute all previous steps, but your website won't reach its full SEO potential without quality backlinks. One backlink from a trusted entity is significantly more valuable than 100 mediocre links.

There are three key mechanisms for determining backlink quality in the new search era:

A. Authority and Traffic

Study the prospective website’s backlink profile using a tool like Ahrefs.

  • Trusted Links: Do they have links from strong, trusted websites that also have organic traffic?
  • Value: A backlink from a highly authoritative site like Forbes, even if it is a nofollow link, is still incredibly valuable for trust and brand recognition.

B. LLM Feeder Status (AI Citations)

This is a critical new metric. Look at the referring domain in Ahrefs and check the overview tab.

  • AI Citations: Does the prospective site show a history of AI citations? If so, this website is actively being used as a source of retrieval for AI platforms.
  • The Advantage: If your brand gets mentioned or linked to on an LLM Feeder website, you significantly increase your odds of getting brand mentions in AI platforms like ChatGPT.

C. Relevance

The target website should be relevant to your niche:

  • Local Campaigns: Relevance might be a local community website, a university page, or a chamber of commerce site in your target city.
  • National Campaigns: Relevance is found in niche-specific blogs, news websites, and industry publications.

The Ideal Backlink should possess all three traits: Authority, LLM Feeder status, and Relevance. However, you can sacrifice some relevance if the site is extremely trustworthy (e.g., getting a citation on Wikipedia, which targets millions of topics, is immensely valuable despite not being 100% niche-relevant).

6. Overall Domain Strength: Consistent Growth

Acquiring one high-quality backlink is great, but you need consistent backlink growth over time to narrow the gap between you and your competitors. SEO is an ongoing game; your competitors are actively trying to beat you, so you can never ease up.

  • Set Targets: Compare your Domain Rating (DR from Ahrefs) or Authority Score (AS from Semrush) against your top three competitors. Also, check the total number of Referring Domains (RDs) they have. This metric sets your target for continuous acquisition and maintenance.

7. Brand Signals and Review Diversity: Proving Legitimacy

Good, followed backlinks from high-quality websites remain a powerful factor. However, you also need secondary signals that prove your brand is legitimate and trustworthy, especially to AI retrieval systems.

  • Product/Service Reviews: Every business should actively work to acquire reviews on the most relevant platforms.
  • Local Focus: If you're local, focus 90% of your effort on your Google Business Profile. Then, secure reviews on two to three niche-relevant platforms (e.g., Angie or Thumbtac for home services; Avvo or Super Lawyers for legal).
  • AI Retrieval Focus: Review diversity is critical because, as of right now, ChatGPT and similar LLMs often do not use Google Business Profiles for retrieval. Instead, they rely on authoritative directory platforms like Yelp.
  • Actionable Tip: Run some of your commercial queries in an AI platform (e.g., "who are the best personal injury lawyers in Chicago?"). Click on the citations and see which third-party platforms are being used for retrieval. These are your immediate targets for driving reviews and brand visibility in the new AI search ecosystem.

Conclusion

The SEO landscape has irrevocably changed, demanding a holistic approach that simultaneously targets traditional Google ranking algorithms and the emerging AI retrieval systems. Achieving success now requires mastering indexation and crawlability (Factor 1), perfectly matching search intent (Factor 2), achieving comprehensive topic coverage and relevance (Factor 3), building thematic authority through topic clusters (Factor 4), securing high-quality, LLM-aware backlinks (Factor 5), maintaining domain strength (Factor 6), and actively cultivating diverse brand signals and reviews (Factor 7).

By integrating these seven critical ranking factors into your strategy, you move beyond mere keyword rankings and future-proof your visibility, ensuring your brand dominates both Google’s traditional SERPs and the new era of AI search.


Contact

Missing something?

Feel free to request missing tools or give some feedback using our contact form.

Contact Us